By and large, the characterizations are rather trite.Authenticity goes for a six.Every character is given some line or phrase to reiterate their ethnicity.But does that make sense? Not really. Amisha Patel never seems to be a Punjabi and is thoroughly irritating(believe me, it is not just her character but her acting as well).Karan Khanna as her husband is decent. Boman Irani's accent seems forced and he seems to be trying too hard (never such a great thing for a man but that is beside the point). Shabana Azmi is convincing but we could have been spared her lecture about 'pyaar' at the end. Abhay Deol and Minnisha Lamba come across as lassi gulping Punjabis rather than Parsis. Sandhya Mridul plays to her type and repeats her stock expressions. Vikram Chatwal is okay.
Dia Mirza is absolutely unconvincing as a Gujarati. Ranvir Shorey could well have been a trump card for the director but he is wasted.It seems Arjun Rampal was forced to do a cameo what with that uninterested look on his face. Kay Kay Menon is certainly not as his best but is still okay. Raima Sen as his wife with ambitions and dreams of her own gets the best written role and she delivers a good performance.
The music is nothing to write home about though two of the songs-'Sajnaji Vari Vari'and 'Pyaar Ki Yeh Kahani'- are decent and very well choreographed. Anurag Kashyap's dialogues are very uneven. Reema Kagti takes the writing credit and while watching the film I could not help the thought that though her direction is generally lacklustre, she did a decent job in coming up with an interesting story idea(though a post on imdb tells me it is copied from a Bengali Natok 'Shomudro Bilash Pvt. Ltd.'...you can always trust bollywood for originality!).
In the end, don't ride the bus...it goes nowhere.
Rating (1.5 on 4)
No comments:
Post a Comment